May 10, 2007

No Beer in Here

We as Americans have this weird propensity to overreact to tragedy.

When the terrorists took down the Twin Towers, we turned our anger into action, and look at all the security measures millions of innocent travelers face every time they fly. In response to various school shootings in the past decade, some have argued that high schools (and now colleges) should be regulated a little more like prisons.

Creating rules and regulations to prevent things that have already happened make us feel safe, I guess. After all, we have to do something. This is America!

In the wake of the tragic death of Cardinals' pitcher Josh Hancock, several teams have continued this trend by banning alcohol in their clubhouses.

Why? Who's to say that Hancock had any alcohol in the clubhouse the night he died, or if he did that it made a difference? If players want a beer after the game, I'm guessing they'll be able to find it.

I'm not suggesting that banning alcohol in clubhouses is a bad idea, per se. It's just that it's unnecessary, a proverbial closing the barn door after the horse is out.

Josh Hancock is gone, and his loss has been and should continue to be mourned. But it seems like no one is facing the reality that creating rules and regulations won't bring him back.

3 comments:

khayward said...

Kevin- while i agree that much of the response is due to hancock's death. It is important to note that men like LaRussa have alcohol issues too. When there's this alcohol readily after a game to "unwind" it's plausible that we might have more of these incidents on our hands in coming years. I'm confident that consumption has gone down in the last 10 years or so as players have become more health conscious, but still it's important to try and stave off the potential of an accident. Hopefully this will benefit athletes in years to come. I applaud these teams instead of writing it off as a meaningless gesture.

Anonymous said...

Maybe they just woke up and realized that part of running a business is protecting your investment.

Kevin Hayward said...

anonymous, thanks for the comment. As for "protecting your investment", you have to realize that baseball players are people, too. People do stupid things, and there's no way to stop them without 24/7 surveillance.