Oh great, another post about racism in sports.
The New York Times published the result of a Cornell study that found that white referees call fouls on black players at a higher rate than on white players.
I tend to agree with the NBA's counterargument that the study's methodology was weak -- it examined the box scores, which contain the names of the referees but don't say who called which foul -- but I took exactly one class in statistics, so I'll leave that part of the discussion to others.
My concern is that well-meaning referees -- white, black, or purple -- will see the results of this study and start to second-guess their subconscious motivation for the way they officiate. So when they do see a foul against a black player, referees will start asking themselves if they're about to blow their whistle because the player is black.
Our society has become very sensitive about race-related topics, but I think there comes a point that we do ourselves a disservice by overfocusing on race. For example, are you nice to your co-worker because he's black, or because you genuinely like him? After honking your horn at a person that cut you off, should you feel worse when you realize she's black?
Race is an important issue, and if we're not careful our minds can become ensnared with nasty prejudices. But hypersensitivity is a cousin of prejudice, and too much introspection can leave us worse off in the long run.
May 2, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
I think the issue is that even if you are careful your mind can become ensnared with prejudices unconsciously. That can't be focused on enough because it is far more harmful and permeating than overt racism. Racism is not just the KKK and cross burning it is subtle changes in perception and behavior that can be far more harmful.
Once at a golf lesson, my instructor had me correct my slice by hitting outrageous duck hooks. He told me to turn my wrists all the way over and try to actually hit the ball with the toe of the club. After hitting a few nasty hooks, he told me to swing normally: I hit a beautiful shot straight down the center. He said you don't fix a slice by trying to hit straight. You fix a slice by overcorrecting, then dialing back to the middle. Maybe as a society, that's what we need to do with racism.
So how is your golf game these days?
Just kidding.
I appreciate the analogy, and you may be right. Perhaps we will have to try out both extremes before we can settle on the "Golden Mean." I don't intend, in any of my posts, to say that racial sensitivity is a bad thing in and of itself. But to refer to your analogy, it seems like we're taking lesson after lesson on how to hook our golf shots. Pretty soon that's all we'll know how to do.
My game isn't bad, although I don't get to play as much as I would like. I'm still straight as an arrow off the tee, especially with a 3-wood. I'm trying to work out the kinks in a new driver.
I hear you what your saying about the repeated hook lessons, but I don't think we have hit the exteme on that side, considering that as a country we are coming from a history of slavery. Besides, you and I may get it, but it doesn't take too much searching around the internet to see that there are still plenty of people who don't.
Correct.
Post a Comment